A Television-ish Discussion...This is a featured page

circletext-2006
Thoughts?
Philosophies?
Random flashes of insight?

Please share your ideas, images, links to websites, videos (or whatever) that relate to television, visual culture, and life. Feel free to post responses to what you see in this space.

How to begin: Just click the "EasyEdit" button (above) to begin writing and/or posting images....Because this is a wiki website, you can write anywhere in this page. *(Hint: the editing tools work best with the Firefox browser)

______________________________________________________________________________________

What about the recent Virginia Tech shooting tragedy and how that has been constructed in the media. There's an interesting compilation of articles and a set of images related to the shootings on the campus on the New York Times online.
Slate.com has an article about how disjointed our visual cultural response to this event and the people involved has been:

I wonder why we react with such intensity to an event that doesn't involve very many of us directly. Is it because when the victims can be anybody, they could just as soon have been us, or someone we know? I think the assortment of visual culture produced in relationship to this event serves as an important example of how visual culture impacts our daily lives but also how we construct events in the media. Think about all the news graphics that have been created to illustrate the progression of events involved, the text message records of conversations happening during the shooting, the shaky cell phone video, and the stories in video and print of the survivors, their families, other students, and community members. Think about the absences.
I am struck by both the similarities and the contrasts with the current testimonies of Jessica Lynch and Pat Tilman's brother and fellow soldiers about how their stories were misrepresented and possible guesses as to why.

Any comments?

Mindi
_____________________

Wow, that Slate article was thought-provoking---thanks for sharing it, Mindi....
I'm trying to wrap my mind around the author's perspective on the Virginia Tech shooting: He calls it "a calamity with no implications beyond itself".... "a non-event" ....and a "slaughter" that "raised no real issues." I don't follow his logic...I guess I can't understand how such an event could have no implications beyond itself--especially if one looks at the situation from the viewpoint that reality is socially constructed and intertextually connected with other realities....

Perhaps a more useful approach than deciding if the Virginia Tech tragedy qualifies as a "real issue" or not is to look at the ways in which issues become meaningful in a culture. What can be learned from this situation about self and others? I keep thinking about the event and how quickly the media moved to seek, construct, and communicate, through images, sounds, and words, a coherent narrative and identifiable characters. What we saw, read, and heard about this tragedy as well as the absences and silences created a particular kind of American reality-story about tragedy, danger, fear, empathy, etc, etc...I wonder if/how television and other mass media shape our expectations/assumptions about how a tragedy should look and sound? ........Vicki


While watching the news coverage of this tragic event, what struck me the most as they showed the police/security running around campus is that the way that they showed it. As far as I could tell, it could have been any campus in the country, including Ohio State. Obviously before you see the footage you are told it was at Virginia Tech but it still gave me a very eerie feeling as I watched it. The tapes they showed of the gunman were even worse. Just an average kid that snapped and what is even worse about showing those tapes, it probably gave other people looking for attention and infamy, ideas and motivation to try to pull something similar...........Chris Frederick

I agree, Chris---the
images from the event are haunting. Also, the gunman's carefully constructed photographic images are very eerie. The fact that he sent the images and his writings to NBC News before the event occurred is also eerie....It's as if he wanted to control, or at least play a significant role, in the construction of a particular identity, even after death.He seemed to have an understanding of the power of an image, especially a news media image. ~Vicki



On a related note, perhaps we as human beings feel a need-- perhaps even a craving-- for disaster. I would not go as far as to say that anyone actually wanted the Virginia Tech shootings to happen, but I do believe there is a reason that such a story seemed to effect so many people who were completely untouched by the incident. The way that the media constructed the event was in the style of a narrative, with characters and plot, as Vicki stated. This type of portrayal allows us to see the event as reality; but it was too fluid and constructed to be truly "real". Therefore, it allows people to feel sadness without really feeling any pain. As twisted as it may sound, I think that everyone gets some satisfaction out of witnessing human misery. It's the same reason why reality TV is so popular. How popular do you think the shows would be if the people on the show were normal, likable people with happy lives? Every form of media, whether it be television, literature, music, etc. is centered around conflict. We, as humans, need conflict in our lives. In most cases, however, we prefer it not to be our own.

I feel I must make a distinction, though: Supporting VA Tech or honoring those who died is not the same as feeling insincere sorrow, and there is nothing wrong with doing so.

-Zach

Yes, what is it about disaster, or conflict, that draws such attention and interest? Is the jolt of shock, terror and disruption caused by disaster something that humans really desire? I don't know..... If watching "happy, unconflicted people" (yeah, and happiness and conflict are subjectively perceived!) doesn't satisfy an audience, then where do we go from there? I have to believe there are more possibilities than the binary oppositions of happy--sad or good--evil that many news programs seem to revolve around. ~Vicki


First off, I have to say that I have very mixed feelings about how the Virginia Tech situation was handled in the media. I can't help but wonder what makes this situation so much more tragic than when one person is shot and killed. Thousands of people are shot every year in America, but for some reason when more than one person dies at a time it seems to get so much more coverage, almost as if some lives were more important to society than other.

Now onto something a little lighter. Lately I've been finding myself watching a lot of the shows I used to watch as a kid, from Boy Meets World to Animaniacs, and the cultural differences and limitaions are so much different in these shows. I'm really considering buying the DVDs of all the cartoons I used to watch so that my kids can share those experiences. It just seems to me like there is hundreds of times the educational value in older shows as we see now. And hey, they're pretty entertaining for adults too.
Marty


I agree whole-heartedly with Marty's statements about the Virginia Tech situation. The media likes to turn multiple killings into a circus and skip over the smaller, "less important" ones. It's sad really.

And with your commentary about older shows, you've hit the nail on the head. This is becoming a major trend. I know in our house alone, we have Animaniacs, Batman: The Animated Series, Garfield, early Simpsons, TMNT, and we watch many shows from when we were growing up: Boy Meets World, Fresh Prince, etc. There's something very comforting about watching a TV show or a film that you watched when you were a child. I know that my parents have done the same thing as well. They watch a lot of the same shows on DVD that they used to watch when they were younger. Hey, we're all trying to feel younger.

-Dan L.

I also agree about the older shows...They are really comforting, I think. It's also interesting to view older shows in the present because age and maturity can alter one's perceptions. It's a bit like listening to old song, I guess---in many ways an old song can cut through all the years of experience and maturity to reach one's heart in the same way it used to, but there's also another level of understanding/emotion that comes from one's present perceptions. ~Vicki

May Sweeps FYI:

A Television-ish Discussion... - Critical MassHey, if you're interested in the latest news about the "May Sweeps" and would like to know the dates for upcoming season finales on TV, then be sure to check out this article at the PopMatters website (Just click on the logo at right). PopMatters also has lots of other articles on a variety of TV shows. ~vicki



Hey -

I just bumped into this video on youtube:
http://youtube.com/watch?v=zOpF_ZGD4Ps

It's a song about Bob Ross with video and soundbite excerpts from his show. If you caught the Scot Kaplan show at the Mahan Gallery in the Fall, this video is a great complement.

Mindi









crit.mass
crit.mass
Latest page update: made by crit.mass , Jun 15 2007, 8:59 AM EDT (about this update About This Update crit.mass Edited by crit.mass

1 word added
1 word deleted

view changes

- complete history)
Keyword tags: None
More Info: links to this page
Started By Thread Subject Replies Last Post
skiball News media 0 May 1 2007, 4:50 PM EDT by skiball
Thread started: May 1 2007, 4:50 PM EDT  Watch
I believe the news media is going way to far when it comes to tragedies that happen in our society. Now i believe that news should be reported but the media goes above and beyond the regular fact of just reporting the events. The media records private moments of people crying over the deaths of their friends and or family and shows it to the world. Privacy for most people involved doesn't exist because the media floods the scene and the town in hopes of getting a glimpse of people's responses first-hand. They bring in specialists and psychologists who give responses that any person with a high school education can say. Then they begin to raise questions about what the possible causes are, Columbine was Marilyn Manson and violent games, Virginia Tech brought about an outcry for gun control. The media needs to be objective and only report the news; not bring on debates about the causes and what should be done to prevent it in the future. Some people are nuts its as simple as that, people kill each other everyday and there will always be people killing each other, no matter if Marilyn Manson goes away, violent games are abolished and there is gun control, there will be always be murders.
Do you find this valuable?    
Keyword tags: None
ERubenstein TV - VA TECH 0 Apr 30 2007, 11:52 PM EDT by ERubenstein
Thread started: Apr 30 2007, 11:52 PM EDT  Watch
One thing that has always particularly interested me about news programming is the speed by which televion both introduces an issue and then how quickly it leaves the cultural news of the day. The speed by which the VA Tech shootings exited "Breaking News" is baffling-- we, as a country, have not even come close to undertsanding the cultural implications of such an event and yet is already off the news.
Do you find this valuable?    
Keyword tags: None
StewartGilchrist Virgina Tech Shooting 0 Apr 30 2007, 7:48 PM EDT by StewartGilchrist
Thread started: Apr 30 2007, 7:48 PM EDT  Watch
I believe that even though tragedies like this does not affect most of the people directly, I believe it is great that our nation reacts so quickly to show love and support. I am glad that I live in a country where people have big hearts and care for others so freely. I know that if myself of someone that was close to me was in a situation such as this, I would greatly appreciate the fact that so many people across the country wanted to do something to show their love and support. Also I thought it was really cool that even in the sports world they had many teams honoring the victims and their families. All over ESPN they shows team across the MLB wearing Virginia Tech baseball caps in honor of the school. Also during Ohio State's annual spring game the players helmets had a VT decal on the side to show that they were supporting them. This weekend I attending a Columbus Crew MLS game against D.C. United and they had D.C.'s colors of their jerseys changed to Virgina Tech colors in honor of the University, after the game they were auctioned off on VT's webpage and all of the proceeds went to the school. Even though it is a terrible tragedy and the news coverage at times was somewhat rude, I believe that it allowed people across the country to learn about it, which in turn brought out the good in Americans. In all it is a terrible tragedy and it is sad that something like this or 9/11 has to bring America closer, but it shows that we are a caring nation and we will do anything for our fellow Americans when they are in pain.
Do you find this valuable?    
Keyword tags: None
Showing 3 of 3 threads for this page